Actors: Warren Beatty, Julie Christie, Rene Auberjonois, Keith Carradine, Shelly Duvall, William Devane
Review Summary and Plot Commentary about McCabe and Mrs. Miller
McCabe and Mrs. Miller (1971) was directed by Robert Altman. Set in wet, foggy, and snowy British Columbia, the film tells a poetic tale about the rise of capitalism and the demise of the values of the old West, underscored by the music of Leonard Cohen.
In the midst of heavy autumn rains, a mysterious stranger comes riding into a small frontier mining town in the woodsy mountains. John McCabe is a drifter and opportunist who knows how to impress the simple-minded locals with dirty jokes, poker play, the habit of drinking whiskey mixed with a raw egg, and a (probably baseless) reputation as the man that shot Bill Roundtree. Sensing the opportunity, McCabe decides to settle down and open up a saloon and brothel in the young settlement.
Life at the frontier is rough and only the toughest, savviest, and most pragmatic individuals survive. Soon after construction begins and McCabe has purchased his first three whores from a nearby town, he receives a visitor: Mrs. Miller, a tough business woman who offers her experience as a whore and brothel madam to help McCabe run his business, while sharing in the profits and supplementing the brothel with a bathhouse, a group of classy young whores from the city, and a comfortable and luxurious interior. Though McCabe is generally averse to entering into business partnerships, he is incapable of refusing the charming and professionally competent Mrs. Miller, who soon takes over all management functions and literally runs the place.
Under Mrs. Miller's auspices the whorehouse thrives, and McCabe soon is the wealthiest resident in town. However, while McCabe becomes romantically infatuated with Mrs. Miller, she never forgets about profit and requests to be paid even for their nights together. At the same time, the flourishing of the town attracts the attention of a major corporation who sends out two agents to buy out McCabe. While Mrs. Miller knows about corporate mentality and urges McCabe to accept their offer, McCabe overestimates his negotiating power. After refusing two offers, he no longer gets a chance for a third but is subjected to three hired killers.
--, Resident Scholar
John McCabe (Beatty) rides into town, plays some poker, and starts construction of a saloon and gaming club, with three "chippies" in tents to service the men. Later, a professional named Constance Miller (Christie) arrives and makes a deal with McCabe: finance the building of a proper brothel with a bathhouse, and she'll manage it and split the profits with him. Of course McCabe gets sweet on her but doesn't know how to tell her. Then a big mining corporation wants to buy up all his property for the zinc deposits underneath, and when he bargains too hard, sends three killers to get rid of him. Like his anti-war war movie "MASH" from a few years before, in 1971 Robert Altman turned the cliches of the Western on their head. A stranger rides into town, builds up the place, is challenged by big money interests and hired guns, and there's a final showdown . . . but the town is in British Columbia, the hero may not be a real gunslinger (despite his reputation), and the big gunfight at the end is a fumbling hide-and-seek in a driving snowstorm. Not only that, but the townspeople not only don't acknowledge their debt to our hero, or help him out, but simply deny there's anything wrong and are totally unaware that killers are stalking him when the fight occurs! In addition, his beloved is an opium addict. Beatty is magnificent in this beautifully shot, depressing film. Watch for Shelly Duvall as a widow who learns the brothel trade, and Keith Carradine as a jovial young cowboy who gets viciously cut down. The soundtrack features the mournful songs of Leonard Cohen.
--David Loftus, Resident Scholar
Click above for the new Obama Girl Parody video!
Analysis of McCabe and Mrs. Miller
Our unique search engine provides a wealth of detail about books by breaking them down into many different literary elements, all of which are searchable (click here).
Ratings are on a 1-10 scale (Low to High)
Plot
Composition of Movie Actual chase scenes or violence - 10% Planning/preparing, gather info, debate puzzles/motives - 40% Feelings, relationships, character bio/development - 50%
Time/Era of Movie:
- 19th century
Western
Yes
Kind of western:
- fighting bad business/family
Main Character
Identity:
- Male
Profession/status:
- small businessman
- gambler
Age:
- 20's-30's
Eccentric:
Yes
- eccentric
Is this an ordinary person caught up in events?
Yes
Hair color?
- brunette (Brown)
Hair style
- short/standard straight (man)
Body type
- average (man)
Unclothed?
- Chest
Events of movie makes character more...
- sad
Ethnicity/Nationality
- White (American)
How sensitive is this character?
- soggy whimpering jelly muffin
- middling sensitive to others' feelings
Sense of humor
- Mostly serious with occasional humor
Intelligence
- Average intelligence
Physique
- average physique
Secondary Main Character
Identity:
- Female
Hair color
- red
- blonde
Hair style
- (woman) medium/shoulderlgn curly
Body type
- average (woman)
How much in movie?
- 60%
Ethnicity/Nationality
- White (American)
Main Adversary
Identity:
- a criminal organization
- general circumstances
Profession/status:
- killer
How much of work is main antagonist actually present in:
- 40%
Intelligence
- Average intelligence
How sensitive is this character?
- hard edged
Setting
United States
Yes
The US:
- Pacific NW
The Americas (not US):
Yes
The Americas:
- Canada
Small town?
Yes
Small town people:
- nice, like Andy/Opie/Aunt Bee
- dumb rednecks, like Gomer Pyle
Misc setting
- building
- church/synagogue
Style
Accounts of torture and death?
- non-gory references to death/punishment
- moderately messy visuals of dead
Movie makes you feel...
- depressed/sad
How many deaths in film?
- 3-4
- 4-8
Sex/nudity in movie?
Yes
What kind of sex:
- kissing
- seeing breasts
- seeing nude female butt
- seeing full frontal--women
- sex under blankets
Kind of violence:
- guns
Unusual forms of death
- perforation--bullets
Any profanity?
- Some foul language
- A lot of foul language
If Soundtrack VERY NOTICEABLE...
- Jazz/r&b
Is this movie based on a
- book
