Movie Reviews
Book reviews

A Guy Thing Movie Review

Read a book review online (click here to search reviews)
Books  Movies  
Sci-Fi/Fantasy Comedy & Personal Dramas Action Dramas
Actors: Jason Lee, Julia Stiles, Selma Blair
Review Summary and Plot Commentary about A Guy Thing
Martin Lawrence and Ashton Kutcher may seem like an odd-sounding comedy team, but in some weird way, they click as voice-actors and cartoon buddies in "Open Season," the first feature from Sony Pictures Animation. It's a movie that kids will probably like, but that may rightly exasperate hard-core movie hunters.

"Open Season" starts out as a back-to-nature comedy about a big, fuzzy hipster of a domesticated grizzly bear, Boog (Lawrence) who's been sent back to the wilderness for misbehavior--getting drunk and trashing a convenience store--by his loving and regretful ‘mama,' winsome forest ranger Beth (Debra Messing). Boog has led a fat and sassy dream life in Beth's town, Timberline, as a showbiz bear, but he gets exiled along with his fast talking, one-horned mule deer cohort and all-around bad influence Elliot (Kutcher), who keeps leading him astray for the entire movie.

So the two roam, squabble and bicker like the gang in "Ice Age." Midway through though, "Open Season" turns into an animals-vs.-hunters tale about lovable forest creatures banding together and fighting back the wave of humans that descend on them every year like locusts outfitted by L.L. Bean. The last half of the movie plays like "Bambi's Revenge," or the forest critter version of Alfred Hitchcock's "The Birds," told from a bird's-eye view.

Led by Boog and Elliot, a battalion of ferocious squirrels, rambunctious skunks, rampaging deer, a wacky duck and busy little beavers with chainsaws all set aside their differences and explode into revolt, attacking the crass, heavily-armed hunters. Most visible and obnoxious of the gun-toters is a snarling brute named Shaw (Gary Sinise) a maniac with a cabin full of mounted animal heads.There's also bossy tourist wife Bobbie, voiced by Georgia Engel.
As for the critters, after Boog and Elliot, the most notable are the mad Scots squirrel-general McSquizzy (Billy Connolly), Elliot's dream girl deer Giselle (Jane Krakowski), his arrogant, fully antlered rival Ian (Patrick Warburton) and blue-collar beaver boss Reilly (Jon Favreau).

The movie has a quasi-hip air; the original songs are by the Replacements' Paul Westerberg. And technically, it's often a marvel. "Open Season" is a computer-animated film with lots of three-dimensional effects and detail, but with a stark visual style that also owes something to the artsy, minimalist look of the UPA cartoons of the '50s .
The directors, Jill Culton (from Pixar) and Roger Allers ("The Lion King") and co-director Anthony Stacchi, try a lot of tricks here-- and they've given the movie the casual visual virtuosity that marks a lot of post-"Little Mermaid" feature cartoons. But they're sometimes let down by the script--which is unoriginal and tends to wander all over the woods.

That meandering script comes from an original story by "In the Bleachers" cartoonist Steve Moore and John Carls, who also executive produced. Stacchi and Culton worked on the story too, along with official scenarists Nat Mauldin, and Steve Bencich and Ron J. Friedman, co-writers of "Brother Bear" and "Chicken Little." And, though it seems funny to say it, the scenario is a little too ambitious. It depends on a moral development in Boog and Elliot we can't see, and on too abrupt a switch from buddy trek comedy to fable of wildlife revolution.

Though the chemistry works in the end, it's still a bit odd to hear dreamboat Kutcher in the gabby sidekick part that would usually be played by a star comic--the kind of smart-alecky role played by Eddie Murphy as Elliot's seeming inspiration, the donkey in "Shrek." Kutcher isn't bad, but he's sometimes too obvious, as is Sinise. That leaves the comedy honors here to Lawrence and Connolly. They're no Mel Blancs, but they get their laughs.

And though "Open Season" is no "Shrek" or "Ice Age," it gets laughs too. It's capable of giving at least the kid part of the audience a good hunter-trashing, bunny-bashing time.


--Afia Ahmad, Resident Scholar

Paul (Lee) is engaged to Karen (Blair) when he meets Becky (Stiles), a zany girl, at his bachelor party. Paul is attracted to Becky and feels torn between the two women. Then, to his dismay, he finds out that the women are cousins!
--Patti Illsley, Resident Scholar

In this movie, Paul (Lee) is engaged to Karen (Blair). He wakes up the morning after his bachelor party with an unknown girl (Stiles). Soon after he realizes that the girl he was with was actually his fiancee's cousin, Becky. After spending more time together, Paul and Becky fall in love. Then Paul has to decide what he wants to do. He could either marry his fiancee Karen; or he could marry her cousin Becky, who is a perfect match for him. This is a hilarious romantic comedy that you can watch with most of the family (PG-13).
--Dashaun Montanez, Resident Scholar


Analysis of A Guy Thing
Our unique search engine provides a wealth of detail about
books by breaking them down into many different literary
elements, all of which are searchable (click here).
Ratings are on a 1-10 scale (Low to High)
Plot
Time/era of movie: - 1980's-1999
Romance/Love/Hugging Yes
Kind of romance: - love triangle/polygon

Main Character
Identity: - Male
Profession/status: - salesman
Age: - 20's-30's
Is this an ordinary person caught up in events? Yes
Hair color? - brunette (Black)
Hair type - (man) short/standard wavey
Body type - (man) average
Events of movie makes character more... - happy
Ethnicity/Nationality - White (American)
How sensitive is this character? - middling sensitive to others' feelings
Sense of humor? - Strong but gentle sense of humor
Intelligence - Average intelligence
Physique - average physique

Secondary Main Character
Hair color - blonde
Ethnicity/Nationality - White (American)

Main Adversary
Identity: - general circumstances
How much of work is main antagonist actually present in: - 60%

Setting
United States Yes
The US: - Midwest
City? Yes
City: - New York

Style
Accounts of torture and death? - no torture/death
Movie makes you feel... - full of laughter
Most similar reviews by Gordonator ranking
Spike of Bensonhurst starring Sasha Mitchell, Ernest Borgnine, Anne De Salvo, Sylvia Miles, Geraldine Smith, Antonia Rey, Rick Aviles, Maria Pittilo, Talisa Soto
Honeymoon In Vegas starring Nicolas Cage, Sarah Jessica Parker, James Caan, Pat Morita
The Very Thought of You starring Monica Potter, Joseph Fiennes, Tom Hollander, Rufus Sewell, Ray Winstone
Murphy's Romance starring Sally Field, James Garner, Corey Haim
Kal Ho Naa Ho




A Guy Thing Message Board (click here)
Movie talk: favorite scenes, what to buy, favorite online
posters, movies for sale on dvd v. rentals.

Search for another movie

Resident Scholar Profiles

TOP SCHOLAR:
  
Patti Illsley  

SCHOLARS:
Dashaun Montanez  Afia Ahmad  


Note: the views expressed here are only those of the reviewer(s).

Click here to bribe
your congressman


Three ways to search for Comedies - Personal Dramas films!

1) One-click plot searches! Simply click on a plot or subplot below!

Animal Story

Comedy, primarily

Crime & Scandal

Ethnic/Regional/Gender story?

Family, caring for sick?

Family, loving

Family, struggling with

Fantasy/Magic?

Inner struggle or disability

Job/Profession/Poverty Story?

Kids growing up/acting up?

Polit/Social/Race/Gender activism

Religion themed film?

Road trip

Romance/Love/Hugging

Sports story?

Taboo Sex Story?

Wandering in wilderness

War impact on civilians/veterans


or
2) Simple title lookup


or
3) Even more search options available with a Detailed Film search (click here)

Use our site!
Feedback
About us

Most recent discussions:

General Movie Talk
Dating Advice
Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire
A Boy and His Dog
Was Vasquez a lesbian?
Was Harrison Ford on Tranquilizers or an Actor's Strike When Filming Blade Runner?
1984
I Never Sang For My Father
The Crow
Blade Runner
Eragon
Slipstream